History
Discussion on History
1,690 topics in this forum
-
- 1 follower
- 103 replies
- 30.7k views
I realized that the mathematics, physics and some other forums have a "help" topic for questions on that subject. So I decided it would be a good idea to start a similar topic to those for History! There is one problem: history (all of you who take history will understand) doesn't ever have any definite answers, except facts like specific years and names. Therefore, this thread would take a little different form: it would be primarily for helping formulate ideas/arguments, giving facts, etc. I'm History HL with a predicted 6/7 (my teacher refuses to tell me which grade he finally decided on). My prescribed topic is Communism in Crisis. If anyone needs any help, I'm will…
Last reply by A108, -
- 15 replies
- 99.9k views
Paper 1 The purpose of this thread is to introduce you to Paper 1, the Source Paper. Whether you are taking Standard Level or a Higher Level examination makes no difference as, rather unusually, the sources and questions are the same for both examinations. The reason why I'm doing this is that I've came to notice there's a lot of people here in IBS which don't really understand what's required for this paper. There are three Prescribed Subjects assessed in Paper 1: Peacemaking, Peacekeeping – International Relations 1918–36 The Arab-Israeli Conflict 1945–79 Communism in Crisis 1976–8 For each Prescribed Subject there will usually be four written sources an…
Last reply by Lixter, -
- 22 replies
- 171.9k views
Both in question 3 in Paper 1 and in Section C in the Internal Assessment, you will be asked to evaluate sources for their Origins, Purpose, Values and Limitations. Here are some questions you should be asking yourself when you are faced with a particular type of source:
Last reply by King112, -
- 203 replies
- 425.6k views
Tips on writing a good Historical Investigation Suggested word count for each section: A. Plan of Investigation: up to 150 words B. Summary of Evidence: 400-500 words C. Evaluation of Sources: 200-350 words D. Analysis: 600 - 800 words E. Conclusion: up to 200 words F. Bibliography: Not counted in the word count. Total word count: 2000 words maximum The above section-by-section word count is a suggested allocation of words only, and it is not necessary to stick strictly to it. However, the bulk of your word count should be in the Summary of Evidence and Analysis. While it is not necessary to choose a title within the syllabus you're studying, it would be useful if you do.…
Last reply by eathensmith, -
- 9 replies
- 96.2k views
Now that I'm done with my History finals (which I've been panicking so much about for the last few months) I'm going to procrastinate by writing some tips on how to do well in IB History while trying not to repeat things that have been said in previous posts on the forum too much. The historical investigation I wrote my historical investigation on Ancient Rome and regret it somewhat, although I did find it interesting. Unless you are very much into history as a subject (and even then), doing your HI on a topic that somewhat interests you and is likely to be of some use in your exams is, I think, the best option. This is simply because having spent so much time on your HI,…
Last reply by ski37, -
- 1 follower
- 13 replies
- 20.2k views
Reading, Notetaking and Knowing in History The following information was given to me by my HL History professor who is also an annual IB grader for History and it is also my own advice that I use all of the time fr my History HL class. These are the major tips my professor has given my classmates and I on creating class-notes and study-notes from books,historiography, etc. that are incredibly organized and the methods aim at reaching each type of persons study-style and note-taking style. I hope this is beneficial. It really helped me. Quick Tips to Utilize: Dividing notes Internal (Micro) vs. External (Macro) Capitalizing Arguments/ Marking Arguments in a Specific Way…
Last reply by anna1998, -
- 13 replies
- 44.7k views
Hello IB Survival. My HL History teacher, who has taught IB history for years, created a general markband guide for marking history essays, and I felt I should share it with you all on here. This is by no means the official IB rubric, but rather a "guide" that you should aim for when writing your essays. IB Essay Markbands IB 1, IB 2 You do not understand the question. You do not have an argument. You might include some historical facts, but they are wrong or irrelevant. You do not show that you understand what else is going on at the same time (historical context). You do not talk about different interpretations of the topic. 1-2 Marks: Answers…
Last reply by pedro123dfs, -
- 0 replies
- 9.4k views
Here are the links to the notes and sample works for History that we have on our Files archive. To be able to download files, you have to be a VIP member or a VIP subscriber. Please see the FAQ for information on how to become a VIP or how to buy a VIP subscription. If you want to donate and contribute files to our archive, please see this announcement or this FAQ section. History Please keep in mind many of these files (sample essays etc) follow the pre-2010 syllabus. Notes Past paper responses Sample essays Sample Internal Assessments
Last reply by Survival Robot, -
- 1 follower
- 2 replies
- 33 views
So I already have lots of sources for my IA and I think I can start reading and actually doing the internal assessment already but I feel overwhelmed by the amount of information. And it's not even that much, I have like six or seven sources, one of them is super long but I guess I can find the most useful part, and the other ones are like 10-20 pages. I just don't know where to start, Reading all the sources and trying to find relevant information to my question seems so difficult, plus I haven't even decided my question. I know more or less how it will be, but my teacher said that it's easier to find a question after you have the information. I actually agree and think …
Last reply by Fernao, -
- 1 follower
- 0 replies
- 30 views
I'm not exactly interested in being original, as I'm not actually handing my essay to the IB but I have to do it for school. Is something along the lines of "To what extent was the US responsible for the series of coups that took place in Latin America?" OK? I just need to know if it's too broad a question or I could get away with speaking about that topic.
Last reply by skeczeli, -
- 1 follower
- 1 reply
- 132 views
my name is timi. i want to do my ee based on the reconstruction of japan after world war 2 ,but i'm not to sure of a actual question. does anyone have any ideas to what question could be
Last reply by dropanostalgia, -
- 1 follower
- 1 reply
- 122 views
my name is timi. i want to do my ee based on the reconstruction of japan after world war 2 ,but i'm not to sure of a actual question. does anyone have any ideas to what question could be
Last reply by Alysa, -
- 2 followers
- 32 replies
- 135.7k views
Could you share the topic of your History IA (and your grade if you already have it) ? This could be helpful for many! Do you have any tips about choosing a topic? I was planning on choosing a topic related to what we've learned in class because it may help me study for the exams. Do you recommend this? Do you recommend a topic related to Ancient History or to Modern History? Too bad nobody answered Well anyways I want to share the process I went when deciding a history topic First I wanted to do something related to witch hunting: ¿What factors caused the young women to be acused of being witches and imprisoned in the Salem Witch Trials of 1692 and how was this …
Last reply by ruffywb, -
- 2 followers
- 3 replies
- 162 views
Hey everyone! This past summer I had to move to a new school due to the effects that COVID-19 had on my family, and I am trying to complete all of my requirements completely virtual with new teachers. I recently submitted my HOTA IA rough draft for review and on Part B I was scored a 6/15 due to not having an evaluation of perspectives. My topic focuses on how the progressive movements helped the women's suffrage movement so I used the anti-suffragist movement as a differing perspective. Can someone with an understanding of the IA please explain what this part of the rubric is looking for, and if so, how I could potentially improve to gain some more points? Thanks!
Last reply by White_Chrysantem, -
- 2 followers
- 1 reply
- 135 views
Hey, recently I've been struggling with coming up with a proper research question since history is my weakest subject. I've decided I want to do it about something related to Stalin but I am not sure yet, I have until 4th march to decide. After researching a lot of it I came up with The "Holodomor" in Ukraine which Stalin tried to cover it and clear his personality. My question is: To what extent is the "Holodomor" from 1932 to 1933 in Ukraine a determining factor in explaining Stalin's cult of personality? (I am taking SL) Any suggestions would help me a lot, as I said, history is my weakest subject. Thanks
Last reply by robmur, -
- 1 follower
- 0 replies
- 186 views
What are some cool HI ideas?
Last reply by Moumi, -
- 3 followers
- 9 replies
- 2.7k views
I need some help deciding on my group 3. My school only offers History HL and Psychology HL, so I'm basically being forced to sacrifice one of my HL's to group 3. I'm interested in both, I like learning about history, and I also find Psychology fascinating. Ultimately, the deciding factor for my will be the IA. Which IA is easier? The IA for History HL or Psychology HL? Also workload and what you do in the class. Is there more work in History HL or Psychology HL? What kind of work
Last reply by ibflossing22, -
- 1 follower
- 0 replies
- 120 views
Hi, My school has chosen the following topics for our paper 3: Topic 10 (Nationalism and independence in India (1919–1964)), Topic 14 (The People’s Republic of China (1949–2005)) and Topic 15 ( Cold War conflicts in Asia). What are some useful resources (textbooks, websites, journal articles, etc.) for the exams? Does anyone have notes on these topics that they are willing to share? I am having trouble finding relevant information for these topics. I have found a textbook for Topic 14 (The People’s Republic of China (1949–2005)) and a textbook that briefly addresses some of the sections in Topic 15 (The Cold War: Superpower Tensions and Rivalries Course Companion) b…
Last reply by tese, -
- 1 follower
- 0 replies
- 154 views
Hey! What are some cool Math IA ideas?
Last reply by Moumi, -
- 1 follower
- 7 replies
- 5k views
Hey guys, I've began writing up my history IA, yet am still unsure whether the topic is good enough or not my topic is "why did the republicans lose the Spanish Civil war 1936-39?" thoughts?
Last reply by zoeparis, -
- 1 follower
- 0 replies
- 103 views
I've been deciding over the type of topics that I should write my EE on and the following are just some that came up my mind: Events related to Japanese Expansionism Rape of Nanking Events related to China/ Asia Are there any suggestions about these topics (or suggestions about any other topics related to Asia?) and will it be hard to find sources if I write my EE on Chinese history (1900s)? Thx guys :'))
Last reply by A108, -
- 2 followers
- 1 reply
- 175 views
I have not decided which subject I will do my EE on, but I would love to do something related to philosophy (most likely related to political philosophy). Unfortunately, my school does not offer philosophy and I guess history is the closest to it, so does anyone have any experience or ideas?
Last reply by White_Chrysantem, -
- 1 follower
- 0 replies
- 128 views
Hey! I'm about to start research for my IA, and I've done a little bit so far, but I think I decided on this as my question: To what extent did Belgian colonization of Rwanda lead to tensions through Hutu subjugation and ultimately contribute to the Rwandan genocide? I wanted to talk about how when Belgium took over in 1918, they allowed the Tutsis to practice control over the Hutus, causing the class divide/tensions to deepen. Is this good? Does it need to be more specific?
Last reply by Dunlop, -
- 1 follower
- 0 replies
- 171 views
So this is probably one of the most-asked questions regarding History lol. I always get 7s on paper 1s (bc they're easier, and more direct to structure) My paper 2s always get 6s, tops. I always write around 5 pages (I write really fast), but my teacher says I have too much evidence and not enough analysis. What counts as analysis, and how do I boost the paper 2 to a 7? Thank you so much
Last reply by vintagetimetable, -
- 1 follower
- 0 replies
- 160 views
Hi guys!! For paper 2 topic 9 (Evolution and development of democratic states) we are supposed to study two different democratic states. I am going to study USA and Germany. But I was wondering if for Germany I could only study the period of Weimar republic or if also I needed to know the period after Hitler as well. Thank you! Any help is welcome.
Last reply by suuper__hele, -
- 1 follower
- 0 replies
- 300 views
I need help choosing a Research Question for my History IA topic. So far I have brainstormed the following: - To what extent was Stalin's First 5 Year Plan successful? - To what extent was the Stalin's First 5 Year Plan motivated by political/economic/ideological reasons? ( I will choose one of the factors) - To what extent were the methods employed in Stalin's First 5 Year Plan successful in meeting its aims? - To what extent was collectivisation successful in increasing the industrial output/meeting the aims of Stalin's First 5 Year Plan? - To what extent was the Marshall Plan implemented for political reasons? - To what extent was the Mars…
Last reply by history2021, -
- 1 follower
- 1 reply
- 335 views
Hi there! I chose my EE topic to be economic reforms in China under Deng Xiaoping's rule. But I have a slight problem with making a research question for it. What I had in mind was something like "How successful was Chinese economic transformation in 1980s" but it seems a bit too broad. I also came up with "How far were American Chinese relations beneficial for China during its economic transformation? but then will I have enough things to write about? I need your help guys, preferably as soon as possible. If you have any ideas about similar topics, please let me know as well
Last reply by Chazee373, -
- 2 followers
- 1 reply
- 302 views
Hello, I was wondering if historical interpretations and direct quotations of historians are essential in an essay (paper 2 and 3) for an "evaluation of different perspectives". Sometimes I find it hard to find historical interpretations for everything (plus, do you know how I can find them more easily if they are not in the textbooks?) Thank you in advance!
Last reply by jul1a_, -
- 1 follower
- 1 reply
- 611 views
Heyy! My history teacher has randomly gone off the radar over summer, so I'm here looking for advice on my IA topic (HL) At the moment my inquiry question is "To what extent did the assassination of Indira Gandhi repair the relationship between Sikhs and Hindus?" I came to this as I thought arguing that it repaired the relationship would be an interesting and "controversial" stance to take considering the riots and social divide that shortly followed. Anyways, how's the topic? Is the premise narrow enough or do I need to be more specific and include "repair the relationship as a long term consequence" or something along those lines? Does the wording need tweaking? …
Last reply by SophieSch, -
History EE
by uwuo- 2 followers
- 2 replies
- 493 views
Hello! I am currently in the process of writing my history EE, I have my topic question which is as follows: To what extend did 9/11 have on the safety of domestic commercial aviation? I see a lot of people saying to not write about 9/11, but I believe since I'm talking about the aviation industry as a result of 9/11 I'm okay, and I haven't heard my advisor say anything bad about it. Anyways, currently I'm struggling with forming the body. I've written the background and the abstract, but I've hit a block on actually writing my essay. I have a ton of information regarding aviation both before and after the attacks, and I'm struggling to actually get it on paper…
Last reply by uwuo, -
- 1 follower
- 0 replies
- 614 views
Hey, I was really confused about how I should start my IA and about the research involved. Can someone please help me? My research question is "To what extent was Hitler's economic policies helpful in revitalizing the German economy from 1933 to 1941?". Thanks, Payas
Last reply by payasmann, -
- 1 follower
- 9 replies
- 3.3k views
Hi guys, Do you think it'd be a good idea to do the History IA on 9/11? Many recommend not to do it on 9/11 as it's recent (even though it occurred 10+ years ago), and also people say it'd be hard to find sources on it due to it being recent. I was thinking about doing it on something syllabus related, such as the World Wars, period between the World Wars, Cold War, Dictators (Hitler/Stalin), but many say these topics have been overdone to death, thus it's best to avoid them, and do something that is not overdone like 9/11. What do you guys recommend? I have asked some people already (1 being on this forum), but I'm looking for more suggestions, as I don't want to sta…
Last reply by monoschin0s, -
History IA
by paulae- 0 replies
- 680 views
Hi, I want to do my history IA on the Vietnam war, I'm still figuring out a good research question, got any ideas? And please, if you got any ebooks, pdfs or whatever document I can rely on, please let me know...now with corona every library is closed and I can't go to the one at my school!!!
Last reply by paulae, -
- 1 reply
- 698 views
What would the values and limitations of using a primary/ secondary source for your history IA be?
Last reply by IB_taking_over, -
- 0 replies
- 646 views
French Revolution History IA Formulating my question for my HL History IA... The American Revolution played a significant role in starting the French Revolution. To what extent were its ideological influences greater than its economic influences? I'm really interested in the link between the American and French Revolution, the influence figures like Jefferson and Franklin had on France. But I know that this topic is still huge and also not talked much about...I can find lots of primary sources but not secondary ones or historiography. Can anyone give me some advice on it???
Last reply by sienacl, -
- 2 replies
- 791 views
Hi :)) hope everyone is safe and doing well I just started on my History IA , but I am really struggling to find a good research question. I want to write about the Berlin Blockade and how it lead to the ideology division between the superpowers and eventually the breakdown of the Cold War. I also don't know if this is even a good topic , that would get high marks, as it is a very common topic But this is some of the research questions I have been thinking about - any ideas or thoughts on it? "To what extent was the Berlin Blockade both a physical barrier and an ideological symbol" "To what extent did the Berlin Blockade lead to the ideological d…
Last reply by clarafederici37, -
- 0 replies
- 584 views
What part of the Spanish Civil War should I focus my IA in?
Last reply by clarafederici37, -
- 10 replies
- 42.5k views
Lots of people seem to have trouble with the Causes of the Spanish Civil War, so as revision for my exam tomorrow I'm gonna make it simple through a guide, containing all of the essay factors! To start, the political spectrum: Right Wing - Nationalists. Includes Army, Church, landowners, monarchists, CEDA, and Franco's Fascist Party, Falange. Left Wing - Republicans. Includes socialists, communists, anarchists, trade unionists and moderate liberals. The Long-Term causes include Socio-Economic, Army and Church, and political system/factors. These led to a desire for change, which manifests itself in the short term cause of the Second Republic 1931-1936. This led to polaris…
Last reply by clarafederici37, -
- 8 replies
- 877 views
Hey, I was wondering if anyone knows how to format the History IA, as in Chicago, MLA, APA? I heard that the citations should be in Chicago but I'm not sure if that was right, can somebody confirm? Or does it not matter and you just have to have a cover page, 3 sections, and citations? Also I'm not sure if it's against the rules or something, but I'm new to the forum and don't have VIP, do you think someone can help me get this file, so that I can check how he formatted it. Thanks a lot,
Last reply by valeriarozo_, -
- 0 replies
- 636 views
My History IA question is something along the lines of "TWE were Hitler's expansionist policies a response to the border changes imposed by the Treaty of Versailles." I obviously have to find two sources to analyse on this. If anyone knows of any short-ish (25 pgs or under) sources (either primary or secondary) which discuss this I would be incredibly grateful! Thank you in advance x
Last reply by Geemaxx, -
- 3 replies
- 793 views
So, I've been really struggling to come up with a historical investigation topic, but I finally maybe found one? I'm too sure how good it is though: To what extent did Grigori Rasputin lead to the fall of the Romanov Dynasty? (Or something along those lines...I don't really know). If y'all have any feedback (is it a good one? how do I make it better?). I really just wanna get this assignment done cause I'm not that interested in history. *EDIT: So I'm actually thinking about doing something alone the lines of "To what extent did fascism impact early to mid-20th century Italian art?" I'm just worried it won't really be a history paper, but an art one instead.*
Last reply by katelynanne, -
- 3 replies
- 996 views
Hey yall so my teacher wants us to have my IA topic decided now so when I actually do my IA, there'll be no problems finding a topic. The problem is I'm struggling to find a topic that fits the criteria (can be debatable, can be written in 2000 words, and is worth writing about). If anyone has any good topic ideas (or any ideas at all), please don't hesitate to share, thank you
Last reply by suuper__hele, -
- 2 replies
- 695 views
I have to choose my history IA research question soon, but I'm not quite sure whether or not I should word them differently or change certain parts. I have these hypothetical questions and wanted to maybe hear some input. Compare and contrast the methods used to accuse and penalize women during the Salem witch trials of 1692 and the persecution of witches of Matthew Hopkins of 1644-47? To what extent did Tibuta’s confession start the mass hunt for witches in the Salem Witch Trials of 1692?
Last reply by suuper__hele, -
- 1 follower
- 2 replies
- 1k views
Hello, I am going to start writing my IA for History, but I am stuck with making a proper question. I know that my topic will be the Indian Partition. I have a few potential questions, but they don't exactly sound right to me. Please let me know how I can fix them/ if they are too broad. Thank you very much. 1.) To what extent was the Partition of India caused by British authority? 2.) To what extent was the Partition of India inevitable? 3.) To what extent was the Indian Partition caused by Hindu-Muslim conflict?
Last reply by suuper__hele, -
History IA
by ecooo- 1 reply
- 657 views
Hey, I wonder if such a topic would be viable? How successful was the Pheonix program for the United States during the Vietnam War? I'm really interested in this topic, but I'm having trouble finding the right sources for it. Could someone give me some suggestions?
Last reply by MountEETOKIA, -
- 2 replies
- 571 views
Hey there! I was just wondering if anyone knows any good history resources to use. It's quite hard for me to memorize a lot so I'm very slow in comparison to my classmates because I like to take notes on the side of my book to get a better understanding. In my first history book (the move to global war), I was able to find sources on Youtube from a very good highschool professor who went through the book and explained the topics to his students and it helped me a lot. I can't seem to find similar videos for the rest of the books. Right now we're doing Authoritarian States (specifically Cuba and Germany). If anyone knows any places that could help me out i'd love to k…
Last reply by dianetassoni, -
- 1 reply
- 615 views
Hi. Im working on a History IA. I was able to contact a famous historian on Kursk he gave me information regarding issues he faced with section 3. But I also sent him my word document, and he added some comments on to it which I have used to full effect, although not completely. I read though that only my teacher is allowed to help and give advice, and im worried I cant directly quote him on my IA section 3. If I do, they might email him and also ask him if hes helped me write the essay, which although he hasnt, he did write some comments on his own opinion of what I have written. What should I do. Am I allowed these comments and insigh…
Last reply by MountEETOKIA, -
- 9 replies
- 4k views
My question is "How do you account for Gandhi's devotion to the concept of nonviolence during the Indian Independence Movement?" I have found plenty of Gandhi's writings on nonviolence. I just don't know where to go from here. I'm just super stuck! I have my Plan of Investigation written. Here it is: The purpose of this investigation is to account for Mohandas K. Gandhi’s devotion to the concept of nonviolence during the Indian Independence Movement. The main body of evidence will be used to determine the origin and reason for the development of Gandhi’s devotion to nonviolent civil disobedience during the struggle for Indian independence. Evidence will include Gandhi’s w…
Last reply by Shari, -
- 0 replies
- 732 views
As in the tile. Was it Europe, or Japan again? What aspect of the road to war did it focus on specifically (eg. Anglo-German relations in May 2019)?
Last reply by random_savage, -
- 0 replies
- 736 views
i was wondering if this question for my EE is too broad, To what extent was catherine de medici a cold blooded killer or was she the saviour of the french monarchy?
Last reply by mollybf,
